In the first two entries in our series on product agility, we discussed what product agility is (Product Agility – Part I: Agility is Key to Competitive Success) and the challenges P&C organizations have in achieving product agility (Product Agility – Part II: Challenges in Achieving Product Agility).  We’ve defined product agility as the ability to react quickly and flexibly to consumer needs and market demands with relevant and profitable products. Product agile organizations react better and faster to competition and regulatory pressure while utilizing data to make informed decisions.  Although achieving product agility is not easy, these benefits return measurable results to carriers who can get there.  In this post, we will discuss key drivers of agility as well as a framework for where to start creating a product agile environment.

WHAT DRIVES A PRODUCT AGILE ORGANIZATION?

In our experience, we have observed six key drivers of product agility. Each one is important and all work together to create an unbeatable organization.  The top-half of the Product Agility framework focuses on the ‘what’ and the ‘where’ associated with product manufacturing:

  1. Presence describes a carrier’s channel approach; Directed capabilities define a carrier’s competency to sell and service through Direct Channels (internet, phone, etc.) while Intermediated focuses on abilities to expand distribution and offerings into emerging channels (i.e. 3rd party, affinity groups, etc.).  A recent Diamond blog addressed questions about the pros and cons of web versus agent interaction and a carrier’s challenge to balance investment across channels.  Regardless of the mix of channels, an agile organization is able to quickly roll out products through their existing and emerging channels and do it in such a way their messaging and image remains consistent.
  2. Offering focuses on how a carrier creates new and expands existing product lines.  Capabilities in offerings are marked by the ability to drive significant quantities of new products to the marketplace within existing product lines such as offering new product bundles or by creating new coverages needed by a new market.  In response to the current economic environment, Allianz now provides an Unemployment Protection product, new to Spain and Austria.  Also, the first large carriers to turn climate risk into opportunity, Allianz, Travelers, Aon, AIG, and Chubb created groups to develop new products and identify investment trends related to climate change.
  3. Consumer Focus is the interaction a carrier has with its customers offering opportunities of service differentiation. Consumer Breadth and Depth describe the ability to expand to new customer types and to increase penetration and market share within the existing customer base.  Customer Experience focused capabilities provide the ability to drive innovation based on changing customer markets and to continually respond to customer’s needs and desires. EBay, for instance, famously received  more than 70 percent of its ideas for innovations through interactive dialogue with its users.  Given Microsoft’s monopoly of “office” tools, it hasn’t been known to proactively solicit customer feedback.  However, for the Office 2010 Team, product innovation begins and ends with the customer.

The bottom-half of the Product Agility framework focuses on ‘how’ a company delivers to customer/ market needs:

  1. Platform broadly describes both technology speed and flexibility across product enabling systems and the information management that supports product related decision-making. Technology Flexibility and Speed focuses on a carrier’s ability to rapidly move from ideation through technology implementation with significant changes to products and/or features.  Product Information Management focuses on an organization’s ability to capture, aggregate, analyze, and share product related insight across the enterprise.  CNA has tackled the technology and process complexity and is capitalizing on its benefits of lower data management costs, greater product reuse, and faster speed to market.   
  2. Culture is characterized by the enterprise product strategy and the incentives and controls used to align the organization to that strategy.  Strategy and Metrics include the ability to measure the effectiveness of the strategy across the enterprise.  Incentives and Controls align rewards across both business and technology and implement controls to ensure investments are quantified and measureable. John Sviokla, Vice Chairman of Diamond, talked about common cultural challenges to innovation in a recent blog.  Google, for example, has such a culture of innovation they go beyond rewarding innovation and expect employees to dedicate 20% of their time to create new things and ideas.
  3. Operating Model capabilities include the ability to manage the product lifecycle through a defined hierarchy allowing the enterprise to align resource needs cross-functionally.  These capabilities also support processes that define, follow, and optimize how products move from ideation through prioritization, launch, and measurement.  Sterling Commerce is an excellent example of a company that has built a strong operating model.

WHERE DO I START?

In order to begin tackling product agility in your organization it is essential that you begin by establishing a common understanding of your current and desired capabilities.  This analysis is a critical step in gaining organizational alignment about where you want to go and how the organization will get there.  This analysis is typically performed in a three-step approach that articulates a fact-based understanding of the Current State, describes a cohesive view of aspirations for the Future State and clearly defines the Gaps between current and future states and the steps required to close those gaps.  The order of the work (current state or future state first) depends on the unique situation of each organization and the clarity of the higher-level enterprise strategy and strategic goals.  Regardless of the sequence of analysis, we recommend that you leverage the organizing framework outlined above to structure this analysis.  In addition, to effectively complete this analysis there are three critical success factors:

  1. Be Comprehensive – the analysis must cover all aspects of the organizing framework above
  2. Ensure Strategic Alignment – the desired future state must be aligned to the broader organizational strategy
  3. Gain Cross-Functional Buy-in – product agility requires an organizational commitment extending beyond the product organization (e.g., information technology, distribution, operations, etc.)

Now that you have the foundational analysis complete you will be in a great position to understand your respective roadblocks.  With this common understanding you are now ready to define the work required to transform your organization and gain a competitive advantage in the marketplace.  How committed are you to becoming more product agile?

{ 0 comments }

Many insurance companies lack an accurate or complete view of their customer data, which may result in lost revenue, unsatisfied clients or costly compliance issues. By implementing master data management initiatives, organizations may reduce these risks, eliminate errors and improve their ability to sell and serve customers. Joshua Schwartz, manager at Diamond, explains some key challenges, opportunities and approaches to implementing a successful MDM program.

This video was embedded using the YouTuber plugin by Roy Tanck. Adobe Flash Player is required to view the video.

{ 0 comments }

In my last post on Behavioral Finance in Retirement Planning I ended with the question ‘Are you on the bandwagon yet?’. If you are not, then may-be you are infected by the ‘procrastination’ virus that most of your consumers are infected with. One of the biggest barriers to consumers saving more for retirement is procrastination. While most people would agree that stashing away a little money into a nest egg every month is a good idea, few would really get around to doing it. Why? The primary reason is PROCRASTINATION. One has to find out more about how much to save for tomorrow vs. spend today, where (i.e., financial institution) to save, select amongst hundreds of alternative product choices and asset classes, contend with a complex array of forms and processes, and many more such barriers. Yet – the alternative of not saving for retirement, or postponing that decision by just another day,  is a no-brainer.

Insurance carriers over the years have experimented with innovative ways of educating consumers about saving for retirement and buying life insurance. We look at three great examples of thinking out-of-the-box and imparting serious messages in a fun way through ‘Games.’

New York Life’s Game of Life

New York Life Insurance Company, in collaboration with Hasbro, has created a customized version of the popular Game of Life, calling it the ‘New York Life’s Game of Life,’ which simulates key financial decisions that people make. Skillfully combining the ‘choice’ that one needs to make (e.g., “Return to School and pay $50,000 or Continue on Path of Life”) at various life stages and the ‘chance’ events that occur during one’s life (e.g., “Hit by a bus. Need Surgery. Pay $10,000″) the Game  illustrates the importance of saving for retirement, purchasing life insurance and long-term care insurance.  The game is also branded with New York Life’s brand message – ‘The Game you Keep, from the Company you Keep’. Ken Hittel, Vice President Corporate Internet, says that the “overriding purpose of the game is teaching the basics of financial prudence and responsibility to children and adults alike.” Darryl Speach, human resources corporate vice president innovation,  goes on to add that:

“Ted [Mathas] (CEO of New York Life Insurance) challenged us to attract the ‘disinterested consumer’ in a new way. These are people who aren’t quite ready to buy life insurance today but who will be at some point. We want to make sure our brand is top of mind for them when they are ready”.

MassMutual’s Right on the Money and Save! The Game

MassMutual’s Right on the Money focuses on teaching kids the importance of earning, saving, budgeting, and charitable giving. A key pillar of this education campaign is the differentiation between wants and needs. A major part of this campaign is the iphone 3-D adventure game called Save! The Game. In this free iphone app the player runs, jumps, and dodges obstacles to collect virtual money before time runs out. The 3-D world is filled with iWannas! - impulse items candy, sodas, etc. that drain cash. The player has to continuously get the collected money to the Bank before one collides with the iWannas! to lose the money. As Nick Fyntrilakis, assistant vice president, corporate responsibility, says:

“Interactive games can be a powerful educational platform for engaging kids on serious topics, and Save! The Game harnesses that potential to bring the concept of wants versus needs to life”. “Our research and experience show that parents are actively looking for new ways to educate their children about the importance of properly managing their finances.”

Visa’s Practical Money Skills for Life and  Countdown to Retirement

Visa as part of  its Practical Money Skills for Life has an interesting game called Countdown to Retirement. This game has a rich set of chance events that occur through different stages of life (e.g., meeting with an accident or medical emergency) and players make choices that fall under three major categories – spending money now for immediate gratification (e.g., going on a holiday), retiring debt or saving money for the future (e.g., transferring the entire bonus into a 401k plan). The player goes through different life stages and based on the choices made and arrives at a point at the end of his or her working life where they have enough for retirement or not. This fun game is a great way of illustrating the trade-offs between current consumption and saving for the future – a key behavioral finance principle called hyperbolic discounting where people prefer rewards that can be enjoyed sooner, rather than latter.

This video was embedded using the YouTuber plugin by Roy Tanck. Adobe Flash Player is required to view the video.

All these three examples illustrate how to take complex and serious concepts and bring them to life by way of concrete examples in a fun way. The first example educates users on complex products such as life insurance,  long-term care insurance etc., while the second and third get to the heart of trade-offs between spending and saving.

While these games are interesting they barely scratch the surface of what is needed to educate as well as motivate consumers to stop procrastinating and start acting. What other techniques have you considered in addressing some of the behavioral barriers to retirement savings? Do you plan to launch similar interactive and fun ways of educating consumers?

{ 0 comments }

Market and Agent Performance Toolset for Insurance Companies

July 26, 2010

Recently we posted a story around the future of commercial insurance segments and how the dynamics of small commercial segment is playing out differently from that of mid-market commercial segments. To put it succinctly, the pitch around small commercial segment is that of efficiency and effectiveness which is about getting more policies through automated/semi-automated underwriting [...]

Read the full article →

The 3 S’s of Social Media in Insurance – Sense-Share-Serve

July 19, 2010

With close to 9 million views, the YouTube video “United Breaks Guitars” was one of the more significant internet memes of 2009 (1). United Airlines severely damaged the neck of David Carroll’s Taylor guitar while unloading his baggage. After a fruitless attempt to obtain compensation from United Airlines, David unleashed a 4-minute song to the [...]

Read the full article →

Treat your orphans ‘right’

July 15, 2010

An “orphan” policyholder in the life insurance sector refers to a policyholder whose agent is no longer working for the insurer. Most life insurance policies in emerging markets like India are sold by agents who often become the primary contact between the insurer and customer. The importance of the agent cannot be underestimated as at [...]

Read the full article →

Behavioral Finance in Retirement Planning – Part 1: Are you on the ‘bandwagon’ yet?

July 6, 2010

On June 29th Allianz Global Investors announced the creation of a Behavioral Finance Center appointing Professor Shlomo Benartzi as the Chief Behavioral Economist of the Center. The press release claimed that “… the Center is an extension of Allianz Global Investors’ continued commitment to provide financial advisors, investors and plan sponsors with helpful information and [...]

Read the full article →

Roadblock #1: Failure to Articulate Your Strategy

June 27, 2010

Case Study:  Legacy Insurance International Eight months ago, Debra Regnis, President of Legacy Insurance International, completed a four-month business strategy to revamp the company’s strategic direction.  It was the first initiative of its kind for the company since she could remember, and she had been at the company for 25 years.  Yes Legacy Insurance had [...]

Read the full article →

Policyholder Persistency – Paving the Path to Profitability

June 27, 2010

India’s life insurance sector experienced a significant slowdown in revenue growth during the recent economic downturn. Life insurers are now focused on improving profitability and achieving break-even as early as possible. One of the key drivers of profitability in life insurance is “persistency” of the existing base of policyholders, a metric that reflects the proportion [...]

Read the full article →

Diamond’s Business Design Research Uncovers Opportunities for Insurers

June 25, 2010

Insurers are in a year of development. Most carriers will grow by either bringing new products to market or by aggressively selling more of their existing products. But, with any new business venture comes a slew of risks. Diamond’s Business Design 2010 study identifies those risks as well as opportunities for achieving success. We are [...]

Read the full article →